GIL BASHE ON MEDIKA LIFE

Restoring Connection in a Transactional Health System

The future of medicine may depend on bringing together the best of its past with the extraordinary possibilities of technology.

The American health system has become remarkably skilled at managing transactions. It schedules appointments, processes claims, documents encounters and measures performance. However, somewhere between the examination room and the billing office, something essential is too often lost: the relationship between people seeking healing and those who have dedicated their lives to helping them.

A patient may receive an accurate diagnosis, an appropriate prescription and detailed discharge instructions, yet leave their appointment feeling frightened or unheard. A physician may deliver excellent clinical care while struggling against administrative demands that leave little time for meaningful conversation. Each fulfilled their responsibilities within the system. Neither may feel that the encounter fulfilled its purpose.

This is the rising paradox of modern medicine. We have extraordinary scientific capabilities, yet receiving care can feel increasingly impersonal. The problem is not a shortage of compassion among health professionals. It is a system whose structures and incentives too often make human connection difficult to sustain.

The challenge is to move beyond measuring what the system does and ask whether those activities help people move toward better health and outcomes.

When Process Is Prioritized Over Patients

The human consequences of fragmented medicine are deeply personal to my family.

A recent New York Times article by Elizabeth Anne Brown, “For Years, She Felt Awful. Her Flexible Joints Held a Clue,” describes the long and often painful journey toward a diagnosis of hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS), a connective tissue disorder whose symptoms can affect multiple parts of the body.

I know that journey intimately. My daughter’s experience, which I share in Healing the Sick Care System: Why People Matter, involved nearly two decades of searching for answers.

Physicians examined individual symptoms through the lenses of their specialties. Neurological concerns, gastrointestinal distress, joint pain and other debilitating symptoms were evaluated separately. Each encounter generated another examination, recommendation or treatment. Yet the larger picture was never part of the exam room conversation.

The cost was staggering, not simply in medical spending and time, but in her suffering, uncertainty and the emotional toll on our family.

The turning point came when a caring physician, Nieca Goldberg, MD, refused to be constrained by the usual appointment time limits. Rather than focusing on one symptom or rushing toward another referral, she listened, considered the broader clinical picture and committed to finding answers.

That encounter began a journey toward an accurate diagnosis and more appropriate treatment. It did not resolve every medical challenge, but it changed the direction of care. This is what happens when a physician sees more than a collection of symptoms and recognizes the person living with them.

In my book, I explore the concept of health kinetics: organizing the health system around patients and their movement toward better health, rather than around the institutions and processes delivering care.

Our family experienced the opposite. Countless transactions had been completed. Considerable personal and payer resources had been consumed. However, meaningful progress remained invisible until a medical expert took responsibility for connecting the pieces outside her specialty of cardiology.

The lesson is not that medical specialization is misguided. Specialized knowledge is essential. The failure occurs when no one steps back to see the whole person before them, who is asking for help.

A system committed to healing must ask more than whether a test was completed, a referral was processed, or an appointment was concluded. It must be the ambassador for whether those actions brought the patient closer to answers, relief and better health.

Sometimes the most essential clinical intervention begins when a physician takes the time to listen and join in the questioning.

The Patient is a Partner, Not a Passenger

Medicine is built on scientific knowledge and clinical judgment. Yet patients bring another essential form of knowledge: the lived experience of their own health.

Dr. Danny Sands, a longtime advocate of participatory medicine and co-founder of the Society for Participatory Medicine, has helped advance an important principle: patients are partners in care, not passive recipients of medical decisions.

Consider someone whose treatment is clinically appropriate but produces side effects that make daily life difficult. The medical record may show that treatment is working. The patient may be struggling to work, care for family or maintain a reasonable quality of life. Both realities matter.

A transactional approach asks whether treatment was delivered. A participatory approach asks whether treatment is helping the person live better.

Research reinforces the importance of this relationship. A 2022 study published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, titled “The Relationship Between the Physician-Patient Relationship, Physician Empathy, and Patient Trust,” examined how physician empathy and patient trust contribute to the physician-patient relationship. Its findings underscore the importance of both in strengthening that connection.

Listening is not simply a courtesy offered when time permits. It helps clinicians understand what successful care means to the person receiving it. Progress cannot be measured solely through clinical indicators without considering the life those indicators represent.

When Administrative Decisions Become Health Decisions

The transactional nature of our system becomes especially evident when clinical recommendations conflict with insurance requirements.

A physician recommends treatment. A health plan requests additional documentation. Authorization is delayed. The patient waits while clinicians and administrators exchange information that may already exist elsewhere.

Prior authorization and utilization review serve legitimate purposes, including evaluating medical necessity and managing resources. Yet when these processes become obstacles rather than safeguards, the burden falls on people seeking care.

For someone facing a serious diagnosis, a delay may mean additional pain, worsening symptoms or weeks of uncertainty. For clinicians, it means time spent defending medical decisions rather than caring for patients.

Responsible stewardship is essential. But a system committed to healing must measure more than how efficiently it processes requests. It must consider whether its decisions help people receive timely, appropriate care.

Administrative efficiency means little when the patient remains standing still.

AI, Health Kinetics and the Human Purpose of Medicine

Artificial intelligence is challenging medicine to reconsider how health professionals contribute value. The question is no longer simply which tasks technology can perform. It is how those capabilities can improve the lives of the people medicine exists to serve.

The debate over AI and radiology illustrates this challenge.

NVIDIA co-founder Jensen Huang has challenged AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton’s prediction that artificial intelligence could make radiologists unnecessary (note: Hinton has since recanted this prediction). Huang draws an important distinction between the tasks professionals perform and the purpose of their work.

Interpreting medical images is a task. Helping diagnose disease, guiding treatment, and improving patients’ health are the purpose.

Diagnostic radiologists often contribute to patient care through their interpretation of images and collaboration with referring physicians. Radiation oncologists and interventional radiologists, by contrast, frequently work directly with patients, guiding treatment and developing relationships throughout their care.

These distinctions matter. As AI becomes increasingly capable of interpreting medical information, the value of health professionals cannot be measured solely by the tasks they perform. It must also reflect their clinical judgment, their responsibility for patient outcomes and their ability to connect with the people they serve.

AI can examine enormous volumes of information, recognize patterns, narrow diagnostic possibilities and support clinical decisions. These capabilities offer extraordinary opportunities to improve health. Yet information is not the same as understanding a person.

AI may help clinicians see connections among symptoms that once seemed unrelated, shortening a search for answers that can take years. My daughter’s journey shows why that matters. Seeing a pattern is only the beginning. Someone still has to listen, connect the dots in the medical Milky Way, and guide the patient’s care. Without a clinician with the time to fill that role, our family has relied (successfully) on a patient navigator, Rachel Lee, our medical “air traffic controller.”

Consider someone facing a difficult choice between aggressive treatment that may extend life and an alternative prioritizing quality of life. AI can evaluate evidence, explain probabilities and clarify risks. But someone must understand what matters most to that individual. What does the patient fear? What relationships, responsibilities and hopes shape the decision?

These are not simply missing data points. They are conversations that require listening, care, and respect for another person’s humanity.

AI can recognize emotional cues, generate reassuring language and explain complex information with remarkable patience. Yet programmed empathy is not authentic human connection. A caring relationship requires presence, understanding, accountability and a genuine commitment to another person’s well-being.

As AI assumes more analytical responsibilities, health professionals whose work directly influences patients’ understanding, confidence and well-being may become increasingly valuable. Physicians, nurses, therapists, social workers and others who build relationships with patients help people navigate illness, treatment and recovery.

Innovation should not be measured simply by the speed of diagnosis or the number of tasks automated. Its value lies in helping people move toward better health.

Technology can help us understand the disease. Human connection helps us understand the person living with it.

Bringing Medicine Back to the Future

In some ways, the future of medicine calls us back to its past.

A generation ago, patients often measured their physicians not only by their medical knowledge but by how well they knew them, listened to their concerns and cared for their families. The relationship was central to the experience of medicine.

That past was far from perfect. Medicine could be paternalistic, access was unequal and patients did not always have a meaningful voice in their care. Yet the personal relationship between physician and patient remains something worth preserving.

Today, physicians have access to scientific knowledge, diagnostic capabilities, and intelligent technologies that earlier generations could scarcely have imagined. Their responsibilities have expanded, and so must their expertise.

The physician of the future must excel in three dimensions: clinical knowledge and judgment, the ability to harness intelligent technology and, most importantly, the human capacity to listen, understand and guide patients with kindness.

These are not competing skills. They reinforce one another. Clinical expertise informs decisions. Technology expands what is possible. Human connection gives both their meaning.

The responsibility also rests with health leaders to create environments where these capabilities can flourish. That means measuring more than productivity, investing in more than infrastructure and recognizing that time spent listening to a patient is not time lost to efficiency. It is time devoted to the purpose of medicine.

Health kinetics offers a way forward. Rather than organizing people around the needs of institutions, we can organize institutions around the needs of people. Rather than celebrating completed transactions, we can focus on meaningful progress toward better health.

AI can accelerate that progress. Better coordination can sustain it. Participatory medicine can ensure patients help define what progress means. But none of these advances can substitute for the relationships that give medicine its purpose.

The future of medicine should bring together the best of its past with the extraordinary possibilities of its future. It should give health professionals greater capacity to heal while drawing them closer to the people they serve.

Kindness, presence and authentic connection are not alternatives to scientific excellence. They are the added essentials to putting that excellence to work for people.

People are not the transactions of the health system. They are the reason it exists. Rebuilding a health system that remembers its humanity begins by making that distinction central to every decision.

PATIENT ADVISORY

Medika Life has provided this material for your information. It is not intended to substitute for the medical expertise and advice of your health care provider(s). We encourage you to discuss any decisions about treatment or care with your health care provider. The mention of any product, service, or therapy is not an endorsement by Medika Life

Gil Bashe, Medika Life Editor
Gil Bashe, Medika Life Editorhttps://gil-bashe.medium.com/
Health advocate connecting the dots to transform biopharma, digital health and healthcare innovation | Managing Partner, Chair Global Health FINN Partners | MM&M Top 50 Health Influencer | Top 10 Innovation Catalyst. Gil is Medika Life editor-in-chief and an author for the platform’s EcoHealth and Health Opinion and Policy sections. Gil also hosts the HealthcareNOW Radio show Healthunabashed, writes for Health Tech World, and is a member of the BeingWell team on Medium.

GIL BASHE

Editor in Chief, Medika Life

Meet Medika Life’s Editor-in-Chief, working closely with founding editors Robert Turner and Jeff Livingston, MD. Not your usual health industry executive, Gil Bashe has built a distinctive career spanning more than four decades across health policy, biopharma, life sciences, digital health, eco-health, environmental innovation, and venture capital. These experiences have shaped his enduring commitment to give back and advance more humane, effective care. A champion for innovation that sustains lives and improves how care is delivered, Gil’s perspective was forged in both battlefield and boardroom. He began in health as a combat medic in an elite military unit, later serving as a clergyman tending to the ill; a health products industry lobbyist in environmental affairs; CEO of one of the world’s largest integrated health marketing companies; a principal in a private equity backed venture; a Medika Life author and Health Tech World correspondent; and today as Chair, Global Health and Purpose at FINN Partners, a community dedicated to making a meaningful difference. Gil is also the author of the bestselling book on Amazon, "Healing the Sick Care System: Why People Matter," a call to restore human connection, trust, and partnership at the heart of medicine. The book reflects his lifelong advocacy for patient-centered care and the belief that health systems work best when they honor the dignity, voice and lived experience of people.

CONNECT WITH GIL

ON TWITTER

ON LINKEDIN

ON MEDIUM

All articles, information and publications featured by the author on thees pages remain the property of the author. Creative Commons does not apply and should you wish to syndicate, copy or reproduce, in part or in full, any of the content from this author, please contact Medika directly.