Editors Choice

Can Doctors “Gaslight” Their Patients?

I was taken aback by the term used in the article published in JAMA Network Open:

Medical gaslighting has been defined as, “…an act that invalidates a patient’s genuine clinical concern without proper medical evaluation, because of physician ignorance, implicit bias, or medical paternalism.” In medicine, the clinician-patient relationship is certainly vulnerable to gaslighting, in which disbelief in patient report (testimonial injustice) may cause a patient to question their own experience of illness.

Source: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2833711#:~:text=%EF%BB%BF%20Medical%20gaslighting%20has%20been,to%20gaslighting%2C%20in%20which%20disbelief

The proper terminology is “epistemic injustice,” whereby a person’s concerns are dismissed by someone else, causing that person to question their own perception of reality, or to make them feel “crazy.”

The article was describing the experiences of patients who were referred to a specialized clinic for vulvovaginal disorders. When I read the article and the term “medical gaslighting,” I reached out to the primary author, Dr. Chailee Moss, to have her come on my podcast (the link the episode is at the end of this article) to discuss her article and the “medical gaslighting” itself.

The findings of the article were eye-opening: less than half of patients said that past practitioners were supportive; a little more than a quarter were actually belittling, and one fifth were described as not believing the patient. What shocked me was that 20.6% of patients were given a recommendation to drink alcohol to relieve their symptoms. Moreover, 16.8% of patients felt unsafe during a medical encounter and 39.4% said they were made to feel crazy.

The actual narrative responses were also instructive, and they are reproduced here:

The most important takeaway from the article and my conversation was that we must do all that we can to ensure patients feel heard. Even if we can’t find something specific to treat, we should do our utmost to ensure that patients’ concerns are not perceived as being dismissed. This applies to all specialties, including critical care. Also, “drink more alcohol” should NEVER be a medical recommendation, in my opinion. It was a very important lesson for me, and it is one I will do my best to remember every day of my practice.

Listen to the podcast episode: https://www.healthcaremusings.com/the-freedom-fighters-of-medicine/

Dr. Hesham A. Hassaballa

Dr. Hesham A. Hassaballa is a NY Times featured Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine specialist in clinical practice for over 20 years. He is Board Certified in Internal Medicine, Pulmonary Medicine, Critical Care Medicine, and Sleep Medicine. He is a prolific writer, with dozens of peer-reviewed scientific articles and medical blog posts. He is a Physician Leader and published author. His latest book is "Code Blue," a medical thriller.

Recent Posts

Medicaid at a Crossroads: Safe AI, Shifting Policy and the Stakes for People’s Health

Medicaid is one of America’s most complex and essential Federal health programs, serving more than…

1 day ago

Global childhood vaccination remains resilient, but equity cracks are widening

In 2024, immunisation data from WHO and UNICEF show that while 115 million infants (89%) received at…

3 days ago

Restrictive practices in medicine are holding high-income countries back

A paper in this week’s New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) is part of a…

3 days ago

The Trauma of Witnessing Charlie Kirk’s Murder and PTSD

The psychological effects of public space shootings extend beyond physical harm because they create a…

3 days ago

Guns, Race, and Profit: The Pain of America’s Other Epidemic

BOGALUSA, La. — Less than a mile from a century-old mill that sustained generations in…

3 weeks ago

Mental Health Secrets Are Being Unraveled, and Inflammation Is the Culprit

Our body’s immune system creates surprising effects on mental health, which people need to understand.…

3 weeks ago

This website uses cookies. Your continued use of the site is subject to the acceptance of these cookies. Please refer to our Privacy Policy for more information.

Read More